1923
Warning : SPOILERS for 1923 Season 2 ’s Finale - " A Dream and a Memory "
Shockingly , Yellowstonescreenwriter Taylor Sheridan broke the Dutton family tree in1923 ’s finale , but there ’s a slim chance that he will redeem it in the next prequel,1944.Jacob ( Harrison Ford ) and Cara Dutton ’s ( Helen Mirren ) warfare for the Yellowstone Ranch came to an eventfulend in1923season 2 . Spencer Dutton ( Brandon Sklenar ) at last made it home to Montana . He serendipitously met his married woman , Alexandra of Sussex(Julia Schlaepfer ) , on the inbound train to Livingston , rescuing her from stop dead on the side of the railway tracks .
After arrive at the infirmary in Bozeman , Alex Dutton gave birthing to a son , whom she identify John , while Spencer finished off the rest of Donald Whitfield ’s ( Timothy Dalton ) and Banner Creighton ’s ( Jerome Flynn ) men . Spencer ’s beloved opt to have their child rather than undergo a life - saving amputation of her legs and arm , which were necrotic due to her extended pic to the unforgiving Montana cold . Alex ’s demise in1923 ’s finalewas a tragedy . However , Alex gave promise to the next generation by delivering John Dutton . Still , her boy ’s nascence may have broken the family Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree .
John Dutton III’s Status As A Fifth-Generation Dutton in Yellowstone Explained
Jamie Dutton Introduces John Dutton As A Fifth-Generation Rancher
Generations flirt a big role in Taylor Sheridan’sYellowstoneuniverse . Ranching is a family business , andthe Yellowstone Ranch has been in John Dutton ’s category for generations . Sheridan represent this by prove different generation of the Dutton family through time . His earliestYellowstoneprequel,1883,witnesses the earliest Dutton house fellow member making a northwest journeying on the Oregon Trail from Texas to Montana . The saga bear witness the first and second genesis of the family tree , and establishesTaylor Sheridan’sYellowstoneprophecy in1883,which says the house will grow over the spread to the Native Americans in seven generations .
The Dutton Family Tree in Yellowstone comprises fictional character from 1883 , 1923 , and Yellowstone , develop with Taylor Sheridan ’s Neo - westerly universe .
InYellowstoneseason 5 , when introducing his father as Montana ’s next governor , Jamie Dutton ( Wes Bentley ) reveals thatJohn Dutton III is a fifth - multiplication rancher . Therefore , we can don that John ’s father , John Dutton II , who we encounter inYellowstoneseason 2 , is a fourth - contemporaries rancher . John ’s 5th - propagation status also means that his kids , Beth ( Kelly Reilly ) and Kayce ( Luke Grimes ) , are the 6th genesis of the family who have occupy Montana . This makes Tate Dutton ( Brecken Merrill ) a seventh - generation Dutton . That adds up , with Kayce selling the Yellowstone Ranch to the Broken Rock Tribe after seven generations .
Custom Image by Ana Nieves
How Spencer As John Dutton III’s Grandfather Breaks Taylor Sheridan’s Story
1923’s Spencer Dutton Logistically Cannot Be John Dutton II’s Father
One of the bountiful outstanding questions guide into1923season 2 was how John Dutton III and his father , John Dutton II ( Dabney Coleman ) , relate to the Duttons in1883and1923.We knew fromYellowstonethatJohn Dutton II and John Dutton III were fourth and 5th - generation ranchers , respectively . That say , we could make bold thatJohn Dutton III ’s gramps , whom he mention inYellowstoneseason 4 , is a third - generation Dutton . However , now that Spencer and Alex ’s baby is named John , manyYellowstonefans presume that Spencer is John Dutton III ’s grandpa . Still , there ’s a glaring issue with this conclusion .
Spencer , being John Dutton II ’s father , would skip a propagation .
While Alex indeed give up a baby named John in1923season 2 ’s stopping point , it does n’t make common sense that Alex and Spencer ’s babe is John Dutton II or that the couple are grandparent to Kevin Costner’sYellowstonecharacter . That ’s because Spencer , being John Dutton II ’s father , would hop a contemporaries . As the youngest child of first - coevals Duttons , James ( Tim McGraw ) and Margaret Dutton ( Faith Hill),Spencer is a 2nd - coevals Dutton . Therefore , Spencer ’s children are third - generation Duttons . That stand for that Spencer , as a 2d - generation Dutton , being father to John Dutton II , a fourth - generation Dutton , would break the family tree .
1923 is a series following the Dutton family during the early twentieth century. It explores the challenges they face amidst pandemics, the end of Prohibition, historic drought, and the Great Depression, as they struggle to maintain their home in the mountain west.
Harrison Ford ’s Jacob Dutton in 1923 solved a Dutton Ranch problem that Kevin Costner ’s John Dutton never hacked in Yellowstone ’s five seasons .
Taylor Sheridan & 1923’s Cast Have Not Confirmed Alex & Spencer’s Baby Is John Dutton
Spencer And Alex’s Status As John Dutton II’s Parents Is Inconclusive
While1923 ’s close hinted that Spencer and Alex ’s child is John Dutton II , with Alex name her newborn baby John in the conclusion , no one has substantiate the evolution , not even the1923stars who toy his allege parents . Brandon Sklenar and Julia Shlaepfer address child John Dutton ’s relation to the rest of theYellowstonefamily tree in an interview withUSA Today . In the conversation , the Spencer and Alex doer were quick to deduct their judgments about their characters ' position as John Dutton II ’s parents , heavy suggesting that anything was still potential :
Julia Schlaepfer : " The only person who could affirm that is Taylor Sheridan himself , out of his mouth . "
Brandon Sklenar : " John ’s a democratic name . "
How Taylor Sheridan Could Preserve Existing Yellowstone Lore And 1923’s Ending In 1944
Elizabeth Strafford Could Be The Genuine Mother Of John Dutton II
Considering Taylor Sheridan has yet to sustain that Spencer and Alex are John Dutton III ’s direct ancestor , there ’s a possibility thatYellowstone ’s mastermind plans to make the Dutton family tree diagram add up in1944,and there ’s one dazzling possible action . For everything to make sentience , Alex and Spencer ’s baby from1923 ’s finale ca n’t be John Dutton II . The child is a third - generation Dutton , so he could n’t have sire fifth - propagation John Dutton III . However , Jack Dutton ’s wife , Elizabeth Strafford ( Michelle Randolph ) , is also pregnant in1923season 2 , and her offspring could be the escape link to the Dutton family tree now .
The massive 1923 season 2 closing curtain confirm one character for Taylor Sheridan ’s next Yellowstone prequel about the Dutton family , 1944 .
Elizabeth Strafford could also name her babe John , after Jack ’s founder . That would make her baby John Dutton , too . If Liz ’s infant were also named John , that would make him a fourth - generation John Dutton , since her hubby , Jack , belonged to the third genesis as John Dutton I ’s ( James Badge Dale ) Logos . If Elizabeth’sbaby was name John , that would click , with Elizabeth and Jack ’s John being the 4th - contemporaries Dutton who could have feasibly fathered Kevin Costner ’s John without skipping a generation . Sklenar saying“John ’s a popular name”is Florida key , with Alex and Elizabeth both having hard ties to the moniker .
Elizabeth ’s baby emerging as the genuine Church Father of Kevin Costner ’s John Dutton III would be a great twist in 1944 .
It could be that Elizabeth ’s son , potentially John Dutton II , will emerge in1944.Strafford ’s child would be 20 class older in the prequel , the perfect age to take a lead use in one of Sheridan’sYellowstonestories . Elizabeth Strafford’s1923endingis left somewhat open - end , with1923viewers not having the slightest thought where Elizabeth is heading or whether she ’s still carrying Jack ’s babe . Therefore , Elizabeth ’s baby emerge as the genuine don of Kevin Costner ’s John Dutton III would be a smashing twirl in1944,and it make sentience that Sheridan saved a bit of the mystery for subsequently .
Source : USA Today
Your Rating
Your comment has not been preserve
Cast
1923 is a serial following the Dutton family during the early twentieth century . It explores the challenge they face amidst pandemic , the oddment of Prohibition , historic drought , and the Great Depression , as they struggle to maintain their rest home in the sight western United States .
