Related
George Lucas is no monster . Though his report has slay some considerable hurdle following theStar Warsprequels , this is still the man who break the galaxy far , far away in the first blank space — not to mention other classics likeIndiana Jones , American Graffiti , Willow , andLabyrinth(producer cite count ) . So , did he make a perfect mathematical product with the prequels ? No . But all things considered , the ripe outweighs the bad .
Except when it does n’t .
When it add up toStar warfare — the series for which this humanity will always be commemorate — those aforementioned hurdles were n’t just unique to Episodes I - III . Even his " untouchable " original trilogy hit a few snags along the way , only to be more or less forgiven . However , assuming you ’re willing to take a skinny looking , the click in the chain are all the more detectable . Call it sacrilege or blasphemy , but assume Lucas was given the Bar Gullet treatment fromRogue One , even he would n’t be capable to deny that some of his ideas that have test to stand the tests of meter were n’t exactly his best .
So , whether you stand in the support or opposition corner of Lucas ' bequest , keep read to check out15 Star Wars Storylines George Lucas Wants You To Forget .
The Trade Federation
The prequels can be tot up in two word : too complicated . Even though Lucas was clearly trying to add some weight to the traditional knowledge of his fictional universe , he made the unjustifiable decision to center his prequels around … a transportation and trade corporation . Lucas himself has posit that this universe is for minor ( even though its most devoted fans would insist otherwise ) , but that did n’t stop him from creating the Trade Federation , a subplot so far removed from anything a child could perchance be interested in that support it , let alone creating it in the first place , is borderline insane .
He wanted to make political strife so as to set up the " wars " inStar Wars . Sure . That ’s hunky-dory . But dedicating so much ofThe Phantom Menace’splot to the woe of dissatisfied corporate leaders , intergalactic trade difference of opinion , and faulty tariff agreements just does n’t belong in a universe predicated on space battles , lightsabers , and the office of the Force .
Padme And Anakin’s Love Story
There are two prominent sexual love story in theStar Warssaga , and only one of them works .
In the original trilogy , Han and Leia start off despising each other . He ’s cocky and she ’s stubborn , so pitting them together was no different than press the ends of two battery together . They just do n’t match . That said , the two are pull into dangerous undertaking together , confront sure death , and by the remainder of a riotous journey , they realize that they have feelings for each other after all . It ’s not peculiarly romantic in the process , but it feels authentic .
In the prequels , however , there is the honey story between Padme and Anakin . Audiences are well cognisant that these two will cease up together ( Luke and Leia would n’t exist if they did n’t ) , but therein lie the problem . It almost seems as if Lucas did n’t put out ready their journey towards romance a difficult one because he sleep together that the result was inevitable . So , alternatively of allowing their relationship to inhabit a sense of naturalistic tempo , it ’s shoehorn . And dry . And coarse / grating / irritating . And … let ’s just move on , shall we ?
Fett’s Fate
Star Warsis filled with memorable characters . Some of them are memorable for their power and scrap acquisition , some of them are memorable for their charm , and some of them are memorable for their aptitude for badassery — a condition consecrate to thestone cold bounty hunter that is Boba Fett .
He ’s a man of few word , but Boba Fett is still turn over to be a favorite among rooter . Existing in the plot of ground only as a bridge between Han Solo and Jabba the Hutt , Fett still manage to stand up out as more than just a human race in a mask . That said , however , when it came to Fett at long last meeting his fate ( which is typically inevitable for " villains " ) , Lucas give him the shaft . Literally .
Instead of snuff it out in a brilliance of glory , Fett gets ( accidentally ) hit by ( a unreasoning ) Han Solo in the back , pink him into the Sarlacc Pit , where he is ultimately accept whole and killed . Had the character just flipped off the audience before disappearing out of flimsy air , it would have had the same effect .
The Clone Army
InA New Hope , Obi - Wan is telling Luke Skywalker ( and the audience ) about the Clone Wars , so it ’s no wonder that they would show up in the prequels . Which they do . The only problem , however , is that they run into a rip all too mutual in anything give nearly three X to build up .
They do n’t go up to the hype .
The actual Clone Wars turned out to be some Byzantine political mess of CGI , and not nearly as satisfying as Obi - Wan ’s dramatic retelling of it suggested . The clones are just discarded copies of some one - dimensional soldier ( who Lucas had the mettle to make Boba Fett ’s father for literally no other understanding than forcing some pointless connective tissue into the series ) , and they change by reversal out to be nothing more than a waste of game and place .
Their eventual betrayal of the Jediisn’t a catastrophe , but it hardly makes up for the power train crash that came before .
Darth Vader Is C-3PO’s Father
attach up loose ends makes for neat and concise storytelling . But only when it makes sense , matter , or is at all necessary . reveal that Anakin Skywalker ( who would of course become Darth Vader later on in life ) create C-3PO is a thoroughgoing representative of when connect up loose ends is completely unnecessary .
Not only did this subplot make little mother wit ( why does n’t Vader spot 3PO ? Why is n’t 3PO truehearted to his master ? ) , it feels shoehorned in just for the rice beer of shoehorning . Which , by definition , makes it awkwardly forced .
The only rationalisation for this plot line is the fact that A ) it had a " gee whiz " factor for the laggard or B ) Lucas had such little religious belief in his original trilogy that he felt at random connecting random characters would make up for any blemish in the plot of ground . Obviously , neither of these points hold any weight , which prove that rationalizing this subplot is unpointed and impossible .
Leia Remembers Her Mom
InReturn of the Jedi , siblings Luke and Leia posture down for a chat . Luke necessitate her whether or not she commend her mother , and Leia answers , " Just a lilliputian bit , " before explicate to Luke what small bits of her female parent she remembers . However , turn over the fact that their mother died during childbirth , Leia ’s memory does n’t really hold any weightiness . Either Leia is a bold - face prevaricator or George Lucas does n’t count this aspect canon in his own series , and either way you reel it , this storyline earns itself a disappointed sigh amongStar Warsfans everywhere .
Had Lucas simply allowed Padme to hold up the childbirth and spend some time with her children before buy the farm , none of this would have been an issue . Alas , seeing as he croak right ahead and discount it completely , perhaps assuming that audience would n’t catch on , it ’s out of the question to guard .
And you could argue that it was simply an oversight , but give thatStar Warsis a multi - billion dollar sign enterprise , oversight is an inexcusable alibi . That ’s just laziness .
The Ewoks
By the timeReturn of the Jedicame around , Lucas could have pretty much gone in any direction he need withStar Wars . And for the most part , the directions he become were positive . The Battle of Endor , Lando piloting the Millennium Falcon , the Emperor getting more screen time … The movie is n’t stark , but it ’s satisfying .
That is , aside from the Ewoks .
Now , in their defense , these animate being are n’t whole unfathomable . They ’re good guys , they ’re scrapper , and they ’re relatively intrepid . However , that does n’t alter the fact that they ’re also oversized stuffed creature that were only make to sell toys and help market the film to a young audience .
By all mean , George , create an alien raceway aboriginal to the Forest Moon of Endor , just make them less cuddly .
Podracing
Podracing in and of itself is relatively entertaining to watch . Whether or not you revel subspecies in oecumenical , there ’s a sure satisfaction in floating pods bankrupt into one anotherat around 600 miles per time of day . But that ’s not the problem here . The race itself is fine . The problem is the entire plotsurroundingThe Phantom Menace’spodracing .
or else of devote this entry in theStar Warssaga to the inevitable death of Anakin Skywalker , it expend most of its timefixinga podracer andracinga podracer . Comedian Patton Oswalt once mentioned in a famous rant on the prequels that including Anakin ’s new ego could probably work if he was presented as sort of Jedi spin on Damien inThe Omen . Whether or not that would have operate , it ’s fair to say that his rendering would have been importantly more interesting than the solid of chunk of time this total subplot wastes in Anakin ’s backstory ( assuming a backstory was necessary to start with ) .
The Luke And Leia Kiss
Thanks toGame of Thrones , modern interview are no unknown to incest . That does n’t mean they necessarily savour it ( one would desire ) , butit ’s by all odds out in the open , whether they care it or not . That said , though , the incest inThronesisn’t an supervising . Jaime and Cersei ’s kinship has consequences that put their entire home line at risk . It ’s a character - influence option by source George R. R. Martin . But inStar war , it ’s a George Lucas fathead .
InThe Empire Strikes Back , Luke and Leia kiss . Not necessarily because Leia is at all attracted to Luke , but because she wants to make Han jealous . In the following motion picture , it ’s divulge that Luke and Leia are siblings … and the whole osculation gets pretty much brushed aside .
aboveboard , we may never understand this one .
“The Chosen One”
TheTwelve Stage Hero ’s Journeyby Christopher Vogler is a formula thatStar Warsfollows to a T , including microscope stage that are stick by to in other piece of popular fiction likeThe Wizard of Oz , The Matrix , andHarry Potter , for example .
However , there is another running thread between these stories that isnotspecified in theHero ’s Journey , and yet is still treat with just as much grandness . That train of thought refers to " The Chosen One . "
Now , while George Lucas is not the only writer guilty of using this image , that does n’t excuse him . Not only is the " choose One " angle stock and overused , it does n’t fit in the wholeStar Warsmythology . This is a series proclaim on science , not legerdemain . It ’s a series that dedicate so much of its apparatus to practicality , and yet , once Lucas decide to make his ominous - fated return in the shape of the prequels , he turned theStar Warsplot into just another slice of garden - variety fiction .
