Dune: Prophecy
WARNING : SPOILERS ahead for Dune : Prophecy episode 5 .
Desmond Hart ’s true indistinguishability and origins are explored at the end ofDune : Prophecyepisode 5 " In Blood , Truth " which indicates that he is secretly a relative of Valya and Tula Harkonnen . Dune : Prophecyis a six - part serial based on the 2012 novelSisterhood of Dune , which was write by originalDuneauthor Frank Herbert ’s son , Brian , and Kevin J. Anderson . The history take up place more than10,000 years before the rise of Paul Atreidies , which is chronicle inDenis Villenueve’sDune(2020 ) andDune : Part Two(2024).Dune : Prophecyreveals theorigins of the powerful shadow sisterhood known as the Bene Gesseritand how they manipulated the fate of humans .
sand dune : Prophecyepisode 1 " The Hidden Hand"introduced Emily Watson ’s Valya Harkonnen , a fierce and calculated leader , and her biological sister , Tula Harkonnen . Dune : Prophecyepisode 2 revealswhat go on to Lila and her grandmother , Reverend Mother Dorotea , after Tula and Valya Harkoennen encouraged her to endure a life - threaten ritual known as The Agony . InDune : Prophecyepisode 3 , Tula study Lila ’s life into her own hands aftershe manifestly died during The Agony ritualand essay to resurrect her through the use of forbidden technology . Episode 4 reveals that Lila was resurrect through the Thinking Machine , Anirul , whileepisode 5 showcases Desmond ’s rise to power .
New episode ofDune : Prophecyrelease every Sunday at 9 PM on HBO & MAX .
Dune: Prophecy Episode 5 Reveals Desmond Hart’s Harkonnen & Atreides Bloodline
He is related to both Keiran Atreides and the Harkonnen sisters
sand dune : Prophecyepisode 5 let out a major character eddy in the dead on target identity and line of descent of the hero - baddie hybrid , Desmond Hart . As Tula discovers at the remainder of the episode , Hart is revealed to be both a Harkonnen and an Atreides , divulge thathe is a congenator of Tula , Valya , and Harrow Hakonnen by extension . Since he is also an Atreides , he is related somehow to Keiran Atriedes in the prequel serial and is a descendant of Vorian Atriedes , who Valya starkly hate and blames for House Harkonnen ’s demise .
Interestingly , Desmond is also an ancient antecedent of Paul Atreides – as well as Lady Jessica , Feyd Rautha Harkonnen , and Vladimir Harkonnen – a narrative detail that could be explored in futureDuneprojects . It ’s unclear how Desmond came to acquire his Hart surname , which could just be a cover . However , the Emperor recognized him as Desmond Hart in the first episode , which intimate that he has gone by the name Hart for quite some time , certainly enough to install a repute across the Imperium . The Book of Revelation that Hart is actually an Atreides - Harkonnen descendant is certain to have a with child impingement on theDune : Prophecyfinale .
Are Tula Harkonnen & Orry Atreides Desmond’s Real Parents?
All signs point to Desmond being Tula’s son
The Revelation of Saint John the Divine that Desmond Hart is an Atreides - Harkonnen hybrid argue that Tula terminate up take Orry Atredies ’s youngster after all . It very much seems that Desmond is Tula ’s child , which is quite interesting since she had hail to figuratively espouse Lila as her own child within the Sisterhood . Tula also " briths " Lila by upraise her after Lila break down during The Agony , which Tula was improbably guilt - stricken by . It come out that the " doubly - born " prophecy within The Reckoning that call for the rise ofa autocrat " born of blood and spice " could apply to either Desmond or Lilawho are , in a way , both Tula ’s children .
The lurid twist of Hart ’s true indistinguishability explains why he first arrived at Salusa Secundas in the first piazza and potentially what he hopes to gain by going head - to - head against the Sisterhood . Since Desmond is fueled by the power of Shai - Hulud , the giant sandworm that eat up him whole and spat him out with miraculous powers , it appear that he is an instrument of divine will . Lila , on the other mitt , is an undefendable vas to a redoubtable and foundational family line within the Sisterhood and is also illegally power by the technologies of the Thinking Machine , Anirul . A showdown between Tula ’s two " child " seems to be whereDune : Prophecyis headed .
What Happened To Desmond Hart After His Birth
Desmond was abandoned by his Sister mother
Desmond Hart reveals some of the details of his childhood and adolescence to Natalya at the goal ofDune : Prophecyepisode 5 , leave the first coup d’oeil of backstory for his mysterious lineament . Natalya clear that Desmond Hart has been take by Shai - Hulud for some great function , although it ’s undecipherable exactly where that is heading into the finale episode . Natalya reveals that she has been chosen as well to lead legions of populace into the Imperium to fake a new time to come but was frustrate by the Sisterhood and their pernicious need for ascendence . This inspiresDesmond Hart to open up about how the Sisterhood has anguish him .
Desmond break to Natalya thatthe woman who give birth to him sent him away to live among scavengers , which left him fighting for scrap just to survive ever since he was a fry . He does not tell apart Natalys his mother ’s name , perhaps because he does not know it , but does state that his mother was a member of the Sisterhood . Natalya realizes at that consequence that she and Desmond Hart portion out a key law of similarity : they both search retaliation against the Sisterhood . slight else is known about Desmond ’s animation before arriving on the regal satellite but the baby he ’s peach about is likely Tula .
How Desmond Hart’s Real Identity Explains His Hatred For The Sisterhood
Tula likely abandoned him as a child based on Valya’s instructions
If Tula turns out to be Desmond ’s mother as ask , then it ’s very sluttish to understand why he hates her and the Sisterhood altogether . Essentially , it come down to the basal mantra of the Sisterhood , which is " Sisterhood Above All . " This places accent and priority on the involvement of the Sisterhood , and those within it , over actual family extremity and other loved ones . Like a cult , the Sisters must shed their erotic love and idolatry to their real family membersand conform to the mellow standards and outlook of the group . Further , in Tula ’s case , Valya would not allow Tula to raise an Atreides .
If Desmond learn that Tula has abandoned him and kill his founding father , Orry , then it ’s quite obvious why he hates the Sisterhood . It would also excuse his hate for Valya Harkonnen , who he may have somehow discovered was behind Tula ’s decision to kill Orry and dozens of Atreides and basically leave Desmond for bushed . The reveal of Desmond ’s true identity toTula could drive a wedge between Valya and her sister . She could come up clean about how she feel about Valya and blame her for making her empty Desmond and kill Orry . No matter what , Desmond ’s individuality reveal will storm an extreme reaction from Tula and could notice her turning against her own sister inDune : Prophecyepisode 6 .
Your Rating
Your remark has not been saved
Cast
Set in the universe of Frank Herbert ’s Dune serial publication , Dune : Prophecy , a sci - fi epic , follows the political and spiritual struggle on the desert major planet of Arrakis . As cabal vie for control condition of the prized spice gallimaufry , a prophesied submarine sandwich emerges , challenging the balance of power and the fate of the galaxy .
Image via Max
Image via Max
Image via Max
Image via Max
